XGF

Ohio State University · Veterinary Biosciences

匿名 · 审核后公开

2.0分均分 · 1 条公开评价

公开评价概览

评价数
1
均分
2.0 分
点赞/踩
0 / 0

匿名表态 · 每个导师仅一次

学生评价

  • 2.0
    ## Advisor Style & Mentorship
    Serious communication issues due to language barrier. This often results in confusion during experimental planning and delays in projects. If you're expecting structured mentorship or thoughtful discussion, this lab is not the place. The advisor is authoritarian and controlling. Student input is often dismissed, and any attempt to set healthy academic boundaries is met with hostility. Feedback is minimal or punitive, and verbal comments can be demeaning.
    Often verbally aggressive and dismissive.
    Has yelled at students for "not being useful enough." Lab meetings feel like interrogations. Not a safe or respectful mentorship environment.
    ## Expectations for PhD Students
    The PI expects students to work far beyond the university-stated 20-hour GRA commitment—often 40+ hours, including weekends and holidays. Students are pressured to deprioritize coursework and are monitored closely. Resistance is often punished, including through grades.
    Disrespectful, disorganized, and demanding. You'll work 6-7 days a week with no clear direction, and still be blamed. She micromanages every step and creates an environment of fear. Avoid at all costs.
    ## Funding & Support
    Be cautious if you're a grad student. The professor has a habit of giving unfair grades and threatening to withhold funding if you prioritize coursework or academic integrity.
    It's not a healthy place for learning or growth.
    There were discrepancies in GRA stipends between domestic and international students. I personally received $150/month less than my domestic peers without clear justification. There is no transparency regarding funding.
    ## Research
    Her scientific understanding is shaky, and students often have to figure things out themselves. When questions are asked, answers are either vague, unrelated, or dismissive. Not a good environment for developing research skills.
    ## Lab Culture
    Toxic lab environment. The Pl expects >40 hrs/week of work, including weekends, and uses fear-based tactics to control students.
    Emotional manipulation is constant, and questioning her decisions often leads to retaliation. Think twice before joining.
    This is not a safe or supportive environment. There is a culture of fear, secrecy, and blame. Students are discouraged from speaking up. Multiple trainees have left the lab early. International students may be particularly vulnerable due to visa dependence.
    I would advise future applicants—especially international students—to exercise extreme caution. The power imbalance in this lab is significant, and there is a lack of institutional accountability.

    No, I don't recommend this PI.

1 页 / 共 1