University of Fribourg - Université de Fribour · Medicine
匿名 · 审核后公开
2.0分均分 · 1 条公开评价
公开评价概览
评价数
1
均分
2.0 分
点赞/踩
0 / 0
匿名表态 · 每个导师仅一次
学生评价
2.0分
## Advisor Style & Mentorship Her approach to mentorship is highly controlling, with a tendency to attribute successes primarily to her own guidance, while holding her students solely accountable for any issues.
## Expectations for PhD Students She sets exceptionally high standards for her PhD students and offers little tolerance for errors. Many students report a significant decline in self-confidence after working under her for an extended period.
## Funding & Support She provides minimal support for professional development, discouraging her PhD students and postdocs from participating in courses or external opportunities that could enhance their skills and career prospects.
## Research There are serious concerns about her commitment to research integrity. She has been known to remove contributors from publications, replacing their work with that of other lab members, and to appropriate ideas originally developed by students.
## Lab Culture She fosters a competitive atmosphere rather than one of collaboration, often pitting PhD students and postdocs against one another, which creates a tense and divisive environment within the lab.
Overall, I would not recommend her lab. Her approach reflects some of the most problematic aspects of academic culture today.
Her approach to mentorship is highly controlling, with a tendency to attribute successes primarily to her own guidance, while holding her students solely accountable for any issues.
## Expectations for PhD Students
She sets exceptionally high standards for her PhD students and offers little tolerance for errors. Many students report a significant decline in self-confidence after working under her for an extended period.
## Funding & Support
She provides minimal support for professional development, discouraging her PhD students and postdocs from participating in courses or external opportunities that could enhance their skills and career prospects.
## Research
There are serious concerns about her commitment to research integrity. She has been known to remove contributors from publications, replacing their work with that of other lab members, and to appropriate ideas originally developed by students.
## Lab Culture
She fosters a competitive atmosphere rather than one of collaboration, often pitting PhD students and postdocs against one another, which creates a tense and divisive environment within the lab.
Overall, I would not recommend her lab. Her approach reflects some of the most problematic aspects of academic culture today.
No, I don't recommend this PI.